Tanfield Railway’s North Pole Express vs the Weardale Polar Express

Tanfield Railway’s North Pole Express vs the Weardale Polar Express

Last weekend we went to Tanfield Railway’s North Pole Express. Last year we went to Weardale’s Polar Express. Given I often hear parents asking which is best, I thought I would compare the two.

Parking and arrival

Tanfield Express

We were booked onto the 2.40pm train on Saturday 10th December, the event was fully sold out so I was expecting it to be very busy. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that at no point did it feel hectic or too busy. The ticket instructions said not to arrive more than 20 minutes early. We found it easy to find – it was well signposted once you got near. We also found it easy to park (although a bit boggy as it was over wet grass so don’t wear your best shoes). Parking attendants helped guide the traffic at all stages. At no point did we have to queue to park or get into the event. The parking was very close to the entrance so there wasn’t hardly any walking. Tanfield Railway did a great job of timing their event so people weren’t all arriving and leaving at the same times. It seemed to be well organised and managed seamlessly.

Polar Express

In comparison, the Polar Express was a much longer drive for us from Newcastle to Weardale. It felt like a bit of a trek with a one year old who hates that car. When we arrived there was a very lengthy car queue just to park. The car park was huge and parking was a bit of a convoluted process and I would definitely allow time for this, maybe about 30 minutes or longer just to get parked. Then there is a small walk to the train, up stairs and a bridge over the tracks which is worth bearing in mind if you have any members of your group with mobility issues.

The train itself

Tanfield Express

How Tanfield Express compares to the Polar Express

Some staff on the door checked our tickets and it was straight through to the train. The train looked fab. A proper steam train, tooting its horn and billowing steam out its funnel. My son was in awe. He’s been obsessed with trains since we watched The Polar Express the Christmas before he turned two, three years ago. As a family we adore the Polar Express and watch it at least 900 times each festive period so these little train rides feel very special to us.

Which is better - Tanfield Express or North Pole Express?

There was no queue or hustle and bustle to get on the train and despite the event being fully booked it was easy to get a whole carriage to ourselves with tonnes of space which is great when you have little boisterous little kids with you. The interior of the train was old school and basic. I’m talking wooden seats, no lighting or heat. Some of the windows were open (so dress warm) and the train was going slowly so we were (probably not the best for Health and Safety mind) able to stick our heads out to watch the steam cascade down along the train through the brisk cold country air. The views outside of the country side were lovely. I’ve seen photos of it in the snow and it looks stunning, unfortunately we weren’t blessed with snow on our trip but it was still pituresque. We must have only been on the train around ten minutes before we stopped at the ‘North Pole’ to meet Santa.

The Polar Express

Is the Polar Express better than Tanfield Railway North Pole Express?

We were really disappointed when we saw the train for the Polar Express. It looked nothing like the train in the film and wasn’t a steam train. It looked like they had taken different carriages from some old GNER, Virgin and Southern Rail trains and bunged them all together. They were all different colours (not in a good way) and styles and it was very long. It looked like some mismatched freight train that you see bundle past a train station every now and then. Not very magical at all. Inside, however, is more comfortable than the Tanfield train. It’s similar to a normal passenger train you would ride on – warm with padded material seats. We had paid for the ‘premium’ seats so we had a table in front of us too which was nice.

The experience/Santa

Tanfield Railway

Is the Tanfield North Pole Express better than the Polar Express?

There is no entertainment aboard the train itself at the Tanfield Express. We saw some kids in their pjs but no adults, the atmosphere was still jovial though. After around ten minutes you disembark at the ‘North Pole’. I think this event is better for younger toddlers who get bored sitting as they get to move about much more than the Polar Express where they have to sit on the train for an hour.

Tanfield Express compared to the Polar Express

At the North Pole there is Mrs Claus’ Tea Room where there is a cafe with complimentary teas, coffees and small sherries for the adults and Capri Sun pouches for the bairns. There are also crisps, apple pies and mince pies. There were enough options for food choices that there was something Arlo could have to eat and drink despite his dairy allergy. There is some kind of big metal burner (neither Papa Ginge or I know what it was called, sorry) roaring keeping the room warm and cosy – it smelled good too.

Review of the North East's Christmas rail experiences

If your kids aren’t as impatient as mine, then you could go to the tea room first and then see Santa but we personally chose to see Santa first so we could relax after while the kids opened their gifts.

Review of Tanfield Railway's North Pole ExpressReview of Tanfield Railway versus Weardale's Polar Express

We queued for about ten minutes to see Santa and despite him calling my son a she, he was a canny Santa. Nothing especially magical but it all ran smoothly and the kids were happy. Arlo is four and his gift from Santa was a battery powered car that spins around, flashes and plays a (I suppose you could call it) tune (loudly). Its super irritating so the kids love it and have played with it a lot since bringing it home (I have contemplated hiding it many times already). Lena is one and her gift was a cuddly dog. The gifts felt like decent gifts – not like you had been ripped off as can sometimes be the case with these Santas.

Comparison of the North Pole Express and the Polar Express

It was timed really well so we had enough time for a cuppa and mince pie etc before it was time to get on the return train before anyone got bored. Our tickets were for 2.40pm and the train back was at 3.40pm, we were all done and back at the car by 4pm. It was a lovely quaint way to spend a December afternoon.

The staff volunteers (mostly older gentleman) deserve a particular shout out for helping to make the event special. They were so personable and affable taking time to chat to the kids and ask them pertinent questions. They really helped make the event special.

Afterwards we went to the cosy South Causey Inn just over the road for tea where my mam and dad had the most enormous yorkshire puddings I’ve ever seen. It was the perfect end to a lovely day.

Review of North Pole Express and Polar Express

Bar Santa and the cafe there were no other forms of entertainment at the North Pole stop so this is an area the event could improve on.

Polar Express

Review of Weardale's Polar Express

Most kids and lots of adults wear their pjs and dressing gowns for the Polar Express which makes for a festive atmosphere. On the Polar Express itself, there is a tannoy playing music from the film and readings from the book which was really fun. They have actors dressed as the ‘dancing waiters’ who interact with the kids and dance along to the infamous ‘hot chocolate’ song, which was our favourite part. My son can’t help but do his own special dance each time that comes on in the film so it was great watching him enjoy it live.

An honest review of the Polar Express train at Weardale Railway

The train stopped briefly at the ‘North Pole’ where there were a bunch of actors who danced in a cute little ‘town’ outside the window and at this point Santa got on. Santa walked up the length of the train stopping to speak to each child and gave them a bell like the one from the book/film. Then Santa left the train and the train went back to the station. You will be sat on the train for about an hour which may be difficult for younger tots. 

A review of the North East Christmas rail experiences

On the way back the staff encouraged/forced people to take part in some festive games. I was dragged out my seat to pretend to be a penguin or something and jump along the train which wasn’t at all soul destroying… Despite my embarrassment though there was much more entertainment aboard the Polar Express than at Tanfield.

Once back at the platform there was a gift shop and cafe you could go to but we tried and quickly gave up as it was just carnage with too many people jostling to get to the same things. Unlike Tanfield, the event felt a bit corporate and more about getting as much money as possible out of you. Again, we had to queue to get out of the car park. 

Value for money

Tanfield Express

It cost us £60 for two adults and two children. Kids under one don’t need a ticket but you have to buy one if you want them to get a gift from Santa. It was easy to book the tickets through their online booking system. We felt the event was decent value for money for a christmas event, definitely not cheap though!

Polar Express

Standard class for us would have cost £64 but we paid extra for Premium Class as we were a party of 4 and the website indicated that this would be the only way we would be guaranteed to sit together. This cost us £109 and that included a babe in arms (which they shockingly make you pay extra for). Personally, I think £109 is extortionate and said we should sit standard class but you try arguing with Papa Ginge about these things!

£64 is ok value for money but £109 is far too much when all you really get is marginally better seats and a cup. If I was to do it again I wouldn’t pay for the premium tickets. While the Polar Express bells are a nice touch I think its a bit naff that for the price you pay the kids don’t get a small toy from Santa too.

Their website is also a disaster and they took our money 3 times and it took us weeks to get a refund. I also think that its poor customer service that given the price you pay for tickets they won’t make any dietary accommodations for allergies etc. Arlo is allergic to dairy products so couldn’t have the biscuit or hot chocolate so he didn’t get anything. I don’t think its difficult to provide for allergies nowadays and they could be doing much better there.

Summary

All in all we preferred the Tanfield experience, despite being huge fans of the Polar Express book and film. I think a large part of that reason was due to the way the events were organised and managed.

At the Polar Express it felt like they had tried to make as much money as possible out of the event by cramming too many people into the experience. It felt too busy with little ones and lots of queuing. I think part of this is that this is ran by an American company so it was more ‘corporate’ whilst Tanfield Express feels much more like a quaint local event which I prefer.

For us the best thing about the Polar Express was the entertainment. The actors dancing to the songs was great but bar that, the Tanfield Express was better at every stage for us.

Due to the high costs of the premium seating on the Polar Express we came away feeling a little ripped off to be honest but of course we could have got cheaper seats. Regardless though, I’m not sure I would spend so much time and effort doing it again now we’ve done it once.

I will say that the age of our children will have influenced our review, like I mentioned above, Tanfield is much better for preschoolers because they don’t have to sit down on a train for a long time. It may be that older children would prefer the entertainment of the Polar Express.

Tanfield Express just felt so much more chilled out and relaxing to us, they clearly could have booked more people on to the train but they didn’t, making the experience so much better. December events with kids are always so full of hustle and bustle and this wasn’t. It never felt stressful and it meant as parents we were able to sit back and actually enjoy it more for once – and that’s something I would pay good money for! We’ll go back again.

Overall scores

Tanfield Railway – 7.5/10

Polar Express – 6/10

Have you done either or both of these experiences with your kids? What did you think of them? Let me know in the comments.

If you have found this review helpful then please don’t forget to follow me on Facebook.

Which is better? Tanfield North Pole Express or the Polar Express?

Follow:

Never Miss a Post

Click here to subscribe to our mailing list

18 Comments

  1. December 16, 2016 / 07:18

    I was thinking about doing something like this with our little one, but she’s too young to be stumping up that sort of cash! The comment about allergies bothers me too as the mother of a baby that doesn’t consume any animal products. So annoying there aren’t alternatives.

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:29

      Yeah, it’s just an open disclaimer on their site that they don’t accommodate allergies which sucks as the hot chocolate and cookie is part of the experience. Of course you can take something yourself but why should you have to when you’ve just paid such a lot of money. I’d save your money till she’s older for sure!

  2. vicki
    December 16, 2016 / 08:12

    We did Tanfield about 6 years ago when my girls were little, they loved it and we found it value for money, we are going back this year as my 4year old little boy is obsessed with trains, I cant wait to see his face, I wouldn’t do the polar express as I’ve heard mixed reviews and we don’t have that kind of money this time of years, with 5 of us going it would turn in to a very expensive hour!

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:26

      Yeah with 5 that would really bump the price up. It’s easy for it to become unaffordable isn’t it. Pleased you enjoyed Tanfield too, hope your 4 year old has a blast!

  3. December 16, 2016 / 09:24

    This is such a good comparison post!

    We’ve only ever done the Tanfield Railway (we recommmend a day out here in the summer too, the journey is a lot longer – pack a picnic and enjoy at Causey Arch stop) and think it’s fab value for money.

    I am a bit like Mark and I would have to book premium seats if I booked the Polar Express – it would probably be close to £150 for us! Yikes!! There’s just no way I’d pay that x

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:25

      Thanks Sam! We will definitely have to check it out in the summer!! Yeah £150 is brutal isn’t it!!

  4. December 16, 2016 / 10:18

    We haven’t done the Weardale Railway but I love Tanfield Railway at any time of year. The boys even get excited just driving along the road next to the track just in case they see a train 🙂

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:24

      Aww how sweet! I love how excited kids kid about trains, it’s so cute! People have been telling me Tanfield is great in the summer too so we’ll have to check that out.

  5. Lisa
    December 17, 2016 / 23:23

    I have been on both for last few years each Christmas, we went to polar express as group of 7 with 3 children aged 3-5-8 and they sat perfectly and adored the entertainment and got involved, they were up with the chefs and got there dad grandad and Nanna involved, the downsides to us was the rubbish planning of ticket collection and Hassel getting on the platform, it is a long wait and long drive and cafe area too crowded, we do however love getting all festive and love on board entertainment, we’re going to tanfield Christmas Eve as tradition and the kids love that as it’s totally different to polar express, they enjoy the steam aspect and the separate grotto, although very different they have many ups and downs but honestly I love them both and plan to book both again for next year

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:23

      It sounds like you have had similar experiences to us Lisa. They are both good but yeah you are right they are different. How lovely to do Tanfield as a Christmas Eve tradition, I bet that’s lovely!

  6. Tracy
    December 18, 2016 / 06:11

    We did the polar express this year with our 3 year old little girl and she absolutely loved it from start to finish. Parking was not a problem, cafe a bit over crowded but all in all a wonderful experience all the staff really helpful and I would definitely go back – listening to the story while having hot chocolate and cookies was so lovely and then watching all of the kids dancing to Christmas songs on the journey back just finished off a wonderful experience. Not been to tanfield yet think we will try that next year too but not sure I can risk not booking up for the polar express too x

    • December 18, 2016 / 06:21

      Oh that’s fab, I’m pleased you guys had a magical experience Tracy!

  7. Georgina
    December 19, 2016 / 11:54

    Wow this looks amazing, shame I’m in the south! I don’t drive (am totally useless at anything practical) but my mum put one of those DVD players for cars up for Wolly in hers. Keeps her from getting too restless! They both look adorable there with santa x

    • December 19, 2016 / 16:15

      You know I keep forgetting to put the iPad up to keep Lena entertained, thanks for the reminder!! I think they have a Polar Express down south too but not sure where. I do drive but I’m totally useless too. I’d happily never drive again and Papa Ginge likes it so I tend not to but I should really! I’m usually too tired from the lack of sleep! Thanks for reading and commenting again Georgina, always lovely to hear from you and Wolly. xx

      • Georgina
        December 19, 2016 / 16:29

        Haha, I would like to drive as it’s so convenient but I’m scared I will be a danger to society! I crashed trying to learn just too many times. Still, it’s a bit embarrassing admitting I don’t have a car and I’m almost 30! We seem to be getting even worse with sleep here – regressed to wanting milk in the night again! At least we have your vlogs to lull her back to calmness haha. I’ve started reading the blog now too, it’s great, really well written. I like writing too, but I have to be in the mood. I read you have a history degree – that was my first degree too, before I trained as a mental health nurse. Are the kids getting really excited now we’ve only got a week until Christmas? Wolly and I will update you after your Christmas vlog, we also wondered which Christmas song is playing in the getting ready vlog at the end – I so almost know it but I can’t quite get there!
        Xx

        • December 21, 2016 / 00:46

          Hey Georgina and Wolly! Well I’m up with Lena in the rocking chair right now, another rough night. We’ve not got past the milk all night stage yet. How old is Wolly? So pleased our vlogs help at least. Lena fell asleep watching songs on YouTube last night, it was the only thing that would calm her down. Thanks so much for the kind comments about the blog too! Love that you have a history degree too! Mental health nurse must be a rewarding but very challenging job. Very worthwhile and admirable career path you have chosen! Lena doesn’t really know what’s going on but Arlo is super excited, plus it’s his birthday on Friday so it’s all go here! The music at the background is just our new outro music from the song provider we use. I’ll get mark to check for you, I don’t think it’s a commercial song.

          • Georgina
            December 21, 2016 / 05:52

            Hi Nyomi! Hope you got some rest at least. I used to try to limit screen time and now I’ve totally given up, whatever works! Wolly is 2 years 4 months (I think, losing count, I used to know weeks,days!) she’s starting to recognise some Christmas stuff but still doesn’t really know what’s going on either although I can’t wait to see her love opening all her presents.
            Yes, it’s nice having stuff in common! I almost called my daughter Nyomi as well but my family couldn’t manage spelling it properly.
            Thanks for letting me know about the music, my brain must have tricked me into thinking it was a Christmas theme!
            Big happy birthday to Arlo! 5 is a great age I think.

  8. Rebecca Griffiths
    November 29, 2017 / 01:20

    Polar express wins everytime for us? took my little one since he was only 8month old, prices are fine, the website says will be seated togethee we never have not been, theres normally 6-8 of us and always been together!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The following GDPR rules must be read and accepted:
This form collects your name, email and content so that we can keep track of the comments placed on the website. For more info check our privacy policy where you will get more info on where, how and why we store your data.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.